3 facts about mental illness to wrap the Kanye West-Don Lemon Kerfuffle

adminOctober 14, 2018





<div _ngcontent-c15 = "" innerhtml = "

Rapper Kanye West & nbsp; with President Donald Trump in the Oval Office. Photographer: Andrew Harrer / Bloomberg

This is what happened:

Donald Trump met with celebrities Kanye West and Jim Brown on Thursday to discuss, apparently, issues important to blacks, including criminal justice reform.

Two days earlier, CNN's Don Lemon organized a panel that included former congressman Bakari Sellers and CNN collaborator Tara Setmayer to discuss the next meeting between West and Trump. & nbsp; The three panel members were clearly upset by the presumption that West could represent the concerns of the blacks or was qualified to talk seriously about any problems. & Nbsp; Setmayer said no one should take Kanye West seriously, given his recent behavior. "He clearly has problems. He has already been hospitalized." & Nbsp; The conversation was & nbsp; accelerated and sophisticated, with several jokes.

The behavior of the West in the Meeting of the white house It included a rapid fire of 10 minutes, rambling. monologue which presented, among many other disconnected points, a reference to the 13th amendment of the Constitution as a trap that could take you to a room with the Unabomber.

After the Trump meeting, Lemon, visibly annoyed, continued to talk about West in the air, saying West embarrassed African Americans who were "disgusting person" while watching him "being used by the president of the United States." Limón went on to say that the West "needs help." He needs to get away from the cameras. & Nbsp; If someone around him cares about him … the family, his managers … need to grab him and grab him … because Kanye needs help … Return from the cameras. & Nbsp; Go get help … & nbsp; Make sense. "

The conservative media criticized Lemon, Sellers and Setmayer, condemning them for "stigmatizing" mental illness. "Mental health professionals denounce the CNN and Don Lemon program for mocking and stigmatizing Kanye West's hospitalization" blared & nbsp; a headline

This particular criticism continues extensively on the stigma of mental health and its detrimental effects. But it is clearly a partisan article. One sentence shows how difficult this becomes: "But to exploit your medical treatment for mental health problems to declare it unworthy to be heard, or to be incapable of a convincing thought, is grotesque."

In the original panel where Setmayer mentions West's psychiatric hospitalization, she is clearly saying that she has observed West as incapable of coherent thinking. So She brings her mental health story as an explanation. It is his observable inability for rational thought that is used to say that he is not worthy to be heard (now), not that he was once hospitalized. Hospitalization is mentioned to reinforce his argument that West is deranged.

So, what are the relevant facts about mental illness?

Stigma

It is true that there is a real problem with the stigmatization of mental illness. A diagnosis of mental illness can have detrimental effects on your employment opportunities, housing, medical care and even your relationship options. Stigma can also lead people to avoid mental health care.

Did Lemon and the other CNN commentators stigmatize West? & Nbsp; The charge seems politicized. Yes, they could have been more careful. They highlighted their irrational and disorganized behavior, which is legitimate and in itself is not stigmatizing. & Nbsp; However, the fact that he had been hospitalized was not relevant and should not have been mentioned. & Nbsp; Talking & nbsp; of this, contributed to the stigmatization suffered by patients with mental illness? & Nbsp; I think it's a difficult argument to defend. & Nbsp; The & nbsp; facts show that & nbsp; his medical history has not kept him & nbsp; & nbsp; After all, he is meeting with the president.

Journalists should always be careful when talking about mental illness & nbsp; even in reference to public figures. & Nbsp; However, it is equally important not to & nbsp; trivialize the concept of stigma by using it as a weapon in partisan arguments. & Nbsp; To get real information about mental illness and stigma, see resources & nbsp; in & nbsp;Bring change to mind.

Is a history of hospitalization due to mental illness or a diagnosis of mental illness disqualifying you or invalidating your opinions?

Absolutely not. & Nbsp; The problem is not that West was hospitalized and Setmeyer was wrong to mention that. & Nbsp; Rather, the problem is whether he has been behaving and speaking rationally and coherently. & Nbsp; It is reasonable to argue that someone can not be a useful spokesperson or advocate if they are not thinking clearly.

Having a diagnosis of a mental illness does not disqualify you from doing anything. Just look at Abraham Lincoln and Winston Churchill, both from & nbsp; who seem to have suffered significant affective disorders at different times in their lives & nbsp; however, they were superlative leaders. & Nbsp; But being actively confused and disorganized, as West seemed to be for most observers, means you should seek help. & Nbsp; And that it is fair that people question the legitimacy of their statements and behavior.

The important distinction between a mental health diagnosis and being in an active episode of illness.

Many mental disorders are episodic with periods of active symptomatology interspersed with periods of normality. In the best case, the treatment puts the symptoms in remission. & Nbsp; This means that you may have a diagnosis of bipolar disorder, for example, but you only have occasional periods of time when you have active symptoms of depression or mania. & Nbsp; If you contract the disease, you may never have active periods of illness. But he still has bipolar disorder. & Nbsp; It is prudent to accept that fact and do two things: & nbsp; one, take care of yourself in a way that minimizes recurrences and two, know the warning signs you are heading toward or in an episode of illness. At that time, you need to get help adjusting your treatment regimen and, well, not going to TV or making important decisions or speeches.

">

Rapper Kanye West with President Donald Trump in the Oval Office. Photographer: Andrew Harrer / Bloomberg

This is what happened:

Donald Trump met with celebrities Kanye West and Jim Brown on Thursday to discuss, apparently, issues important to blacks, including criminal justice reform.

Two days earlier, CNN's Don Lemon organized a panel that included former Congressman Bakari Sellers and CNN's Tara Setmayer to discuss the next meeting between West and Trump. The three members of the panel were clearly upset by the presumption that West could represent the concerns of black people or was qualified to speak seriously on any subject. Setmayer said no one should take Kanye West seriously, given his recent behavior. "He clearly has problems, he's already been hospitalized." The conversation was quick and sophisticated, with several jokes.

West's behavior at the White House meeting included a 10-minute walking monologue that included, among many other disconnected points, a reference to the 13th amendment of the Constitution as a trap that could take you to a room with the Unabomber.

After the Trump meeting, Lemon, visibly annoyed, continued to talk about West in the air, saying West embarrassed the African Americans who were "shaking" as they watched him "being used by the President of the United States." Lemon went on to say that West "needs help, he needs to get out of the cameras, if someone around him cares about him … the family, his managers … they need to grab him and grab him … because Kanye needs help … Come back from the cameras, go get help … It makes sense. "

The conservative media criticized Lemon, Sellers and Setmayer, condemning them for "stigmatizing" mental illness. "Mental health professionals denounce the program of CNN and Don Lemon for mocking and stigmatizing the hospitalization of Kanye West," said a headline.

This particular criticism continues extensively on the stigma of mental health and its detrimental effects. But it is clearly a partisan article. One sentence shows how difficult this becomes: "But to exploit your medical treatment for mental health problems to declare it unworthy to be heard, or to be incapable of a convincing thought, is grotesque."

In the original panel where Setmayer mentions West's psychiatric hospitalization, she is clearly saying that she has observed West as incapable of coherent thinking. So She brings her mental health story as an explanation. It is his observable inability for rational thought that is used to say that he is not worthy to be heard (now), not that he was once hospitalized. Hospitalization is mentioned to reinforce his argument that West is deranged.

So, what are the relevant facts about mental illness?

Stigma

It is true that there is a real problem with the stigmatization of mental illness. A diagnosis of mental illness can have detrimental effects on your employment opportunities, housing, medical care and even your relationship options. Stigma can also lead people to avoid mental health care.

Did Lemon and the other CNN commentators stigmatize West? The charge seems politicized. Yes, they could have been more careful. They highlighted their irrational and disorganized behavior, which is legitimate and in itself is not stigmatizing. However, the fact that he had been hospitalized was not relevant and should not have been mentioned. Did talking about it contribute to the stigmatization suffered by patients with mental illness? I think it's a difficult argument to defend. The facts actually show that his medical history did not stop him. After all, he is meeting with the president.

Journalists should always be careful when talking about mental illness, even in reference to public figures. However, it is equally important not to trivialize the concept of stigma by using it as a weapon in partisan arguments. To get real information about mental illness and stigma, see the resources in Bring Change to Mind.

Is a history of hospitalization due to mental illness or a diagnosis of mental illness disqualifying you or invalidating your opinions?

Absolutely not. The problem is not that West was hospitalized and Setmeyer was wrong to mention that. Rather, the problem is whether he has been behaving and speaking rationally and coherently. It is reasonable to argue that someone can not be a useful spokesperson or advocate if they are not thinking clearly.

Having a diagnosis of a mental illness does not disqualify you from doing anything. One has only to look at Abraham Lincoln and Winston Churchill, who seem to have suffered significant affective disorders at different times in their lives, yet they were superlative leaders. But being actively confused and disorganized, as West seemed to be for most observers, means you should seek help. And that it is fair that people question the legitimacy of their statements and behavior.

The important distinction between a mental health diagnosis and being in an active episode of illness.

Many mental disorders are episodic with periods of active symptomatology interspersed with periods of normality. In the best case, the treatment puts the symptoms in remission. This means that you may have a diagnosis of bipolar disorder, for example, but you only have occasional periods of time when you have active symptoms of depression or mania. If you contract the disease, you may never have active periods of illness. But you still have bipolar disorder. It is prudent to accept that fact and do two things: one, take care of yourself in a way that minimizes recurrences and two, know the warning signs you are addressing or in an episode of illness. At that time, you need to get help adjusting your treatment regimen and, well, not going to TV or making important decisions or speeches.



Source link

Categories